BookieSlip
MLB · 2026-05-15
New York Yankees logo
NYY
New York Yankees
at
Tonight 7:05 PM ET
Baltimore Orioles logo
BAL
Baltimore Orioles
The Pick
Baltimore Orioles
Moneyline · -118
Confidence
STRONG
Edge
+2.0pp
Model Win
55.5%
Fair Odds
-125
Kelly Stake
1.2u

The Edge, Visualized

Our model's win probability vs. the market's implied probability. The gap is the edge.

Our Model 55.5%
Market Implied 54.1%
+2.0pp edge in our favor. The market is pricing Baltimore Orioles at -118 (54.1% implied), we think they win 55.5% of the time.
Our Model
55.5%
win probability · fair odds -125
The Book
54.1%
implied · current odds -118

The Matchup

New York Yankees logo NYY Stat BAL Baltimore Orioles logo
23-19 Record 24-18
.548 Win % .571
4.91 Runs/G 4.74
4-6 Last 10 7-3
4-6 road Road / Home 7-3 home
4.12 Bullpen ERA 3.41
.228 Avg vs RHP .262

Anatomy of the Pick

Every factor that moved the model. Every number sourced — no hallucinations.

TL;DR

The Baltimore Orioles at -118 present a +2.0% expected-value opportunity against the Yankees in today's slate. Supreme Brain assigns the Orioles a 55.5% win probability versus a 53.5% market-implied probability at the current price, producing a fair price of -125. The edge rests on Baltimore's recent home form—7-3 in their last 10 games at Camden Yards—and New York's road struggles at 4-6 over their last 10 away contests. The Orioles bullpen has posted a 3.41 ERA over the last 30 days, while the Yankees are batting just .228 against right-handed pitching this month. Home favorites in the -110 to -130 odds band have hit at 56% over 124 settled games, a rate that aligns with Baltimore's model probability. The two-point edge is modest but real.

Supreme Brain assigns the Baltimore Orioles a 55.5% win probability against the Yankees at -118 odds, a two-point gap over the 53.5% market-implied probability that produces a fair price of -125. The Orioles are 7-3 in their last 10 games at home; the Yankees are 4-6 in their last 10 on the road.

Baltimore offers a +2.0% expected-value edge on the moneyline, driven by home-field advantage, bullpen stability, and New York's recent road volatility—Supreme Brain's 55.5% win probability sits comfortably above the market's 53.5% implied rate.

Why we like it

How this loses

The thesis breaks if the Yankees' lineup wakes up against right-handed pitching or if Baltimore's bullpen falters in a high-leverage spot. A two-point edge leaves little room for variance; if New York's road offense reverts to its seasonal mean or if the Orioles' relievers allow a late crooked number, the model's advantage evaporates. Watch for early signs of life from the Yankees' bats—if they string together quality at-bats in the first three innings, the probability gap narrows quickly.

The Orioles at -118 are not a gift, but they are mispriced. A 7-3 home record in the last 10 games and a bullpen ERA of 3.41 over the last 30 days provide the foundation for a modest, repeatable edge.
FREE · Mon–Thu · No Credit Card
Get tonight's Pick of the Day — free.
The Supreme Brain — our 56-module prediction engine running on five years of SportsDataIO history — fires its single highest-conviction MLB pick. We send it to you Monday through Thursday, in your inbox by 6 AM ET — including the full source-attributed thesis, calibration data, and what we'd stake. Next drop: next Monday morning.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime. 21+. 1-800-GAMBLER. Bet responsibly. Picks are for entertainment; past performance does not guarantee future results.